#Raysupreme 3d pdf trial#

#Raysupreme 3d pdf trial#

On appeal, petitioner Jones was accorded a trial de novo in the County Court, and, after the city produced its evidence, the court granted his motion for a directed verdict. They were each given the maximum sentence of four months in jail andĪ fine of $200. Petitioners waived a jury trial and were convicted of the offense by respondent Spencer, a municipal police justice. They were arrested by respondents Ray, Griffith, and Nichols, policemen of the City of Jackson, and charged with violating § 2087.5 of the Mississippi Code, which makes guilty of a misdemeanor anyone who congregates with others in a public place under circumstances such that a breach of the peace may be occasioned thereby, and refuses to move on when ordered to do so by a police officer. 79 were members of a group of 15 white and Negro Episcopal clergymen who attempted to use segregated facilities at an interstate bus terminal in Jackson Mississippi, in 1961. These cases present issues involving the liability of local police officers and judges under § 1 of the Civil Rights Act of 1871, 17 Stat. CHIEF JUSTICE WARREN delivered the opinion of Court. & 213, affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded.ĬERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS Petitioners did not consent to their arrest by deliberately exercising their right to use the waiting room in a peaceful manner with the expectation that they would be illegally arrested. Mississippi, supra, that § 2087.5 was unconstitutional as applied, and the defense of good faith and probable cause is available in an action under § 1983, it does not follow that the count based thereon should be dismissed, since the evidence was conflicting as to whether the police had acted in good faith and with probable cause in arresting the petitioners. Though the officers were not required to predict this Court's ruling in Thomas v. The defense of good faith and probable cause which is available to police officers in a common law action for false arrest and imprisonment is also available in an action under § 1983. The settled common law principle that a judge is immune from liability for damages for his judicial acts was not abolished by § 1983. The court remanded the case against the officers for a new trial under § 1983 because of prejudicial cross-examination of petitioners, but ruled that theyĬould not recover if it were shown at the new trial that they had gone to Mississippi in anticipation that they would be illegally arrested.ġ. 167, they had no such immunity under § 1983 where the state statute was subsequently declared invalid. On appeal, the Court of Appeals held that (1) respondent police justice had immunity for his judicial acts under both § 1983 and the state common law and (2) the policemen had immunity under the state common law of false arrest if they had probable cause to believe § 2087.5 valid, since they were not required to predict what laws are constitutional, but that, by virtue of Monroe v. Though the witnesses agreed that petitioners entered the waiting room peacefully, petitioners testified that there was no crowd at the terminal, whereas the police testified that a threatening crowd followed petitioners.

The evidence showed that the ministers expected to be arrested on entering a segregated area.

§ 1983, which makes liable 'every person' who under color of law deprives another person of his civil rights, and (2) at common law for false arrest and imprisonment. Petitioners then brought this action in the District Court for damages (1) under 42 U.S.C.

On appeal, one petitioner was accorded a trial de novo and, following a directed verdict in his favor, the cases against the other petitioners were dropped. Petitioners waived a jury trial, and were convicted by respondent municipal police justice. They were arrested by respondent policemen and charged with conduct breaching the peace in violation of § 2087.5 of the Mississippi Code, which this Court, in 1965, held unconstitutional in Thomas v. Petitioners,** members of a group of white and Negro clergymen on a 'prayer pilgrimage' to promote racial integration, attempted to use a segregated interstate bus terminal waiting room in Jackson, Mississippi, in 1961.